Question about UR13 rule of JED - Joomla! Forum - community, help and support

our extension j2store unpublished under rule ur - 13 bait , switch.

when submitted ticket, reply was:

the listing needs marked commercial. appears extension isn't functional unless buy payment plugins.

any listing requires payment functional must marked commercial if main extension free.

my arguement is:

1. j2store comes offline payment plugin , functional it. hundreds of users use receive orders.

2. more important one:

- many extensions have pro version functions.
- many want these functions. basic version not function (as per case jed)
- extensions have pro version should marked commercial.

how these:
http://www.nonumber.nl/
http://www.hikashop.com/en/download.html

why not nbill. pro version encrypted. can point hundreds of extensions violate norm.

even virtuemart should commercial. because has paid extensions.

3. if online payment option not present, not functional (that case made jed). fine.
- there 100 payment gateways across world.
- let assume, want web money or integrated bank.
- j2store or other extensions dont have.
- means extensions not functional me.
- need hire developer build integration.
so such extensions should me marked commercial.

if apply logic, every extension in jed commercial.

our case:

we keep j2store free. released under gpl. functional without online payment plugins.

we have many users use j2store take orders. photoframe makers order , later charge it.

our humble request jed should consider angles before taking negative action.

your logic flawed. of extensions point out don't advertise features/functions not included in non-commercial versions.